| Opossum | Didelphis virginianus | | |
| White-tailed Deer | Odocoileus virginianus | | |
| Fox Squirrel | Sciurus niger | | |
| Eastern Gray Squirrel | Sciurus carolinensis | | |
| Eastern Chipmunk | Tamias striatus | | |
| Groundhog | Marmota monax | | |
| Red Squirrel | Tamiasciurus hudsonicus | | |
| Southern Flying Squirrel | Glaucomys volans | | |
| Muskrat | Ondatra zibethicus | | |
| Eastern Mole | Scalopus aquaticus | ||
| Northern Short-tailed Shrew | Blarina brevicauda | ||
| Masked Shrew | Sorex cinereus | ||
| Meadow Vole | Microtus pennsylvanicus | ||
| Deer Mouse | Peromyscus maniculatus | ||
| White-footed Mouse | Peromyscus leucopus | ||
| Eastern Cottontail | Sylvilagus floridanus | | |
| Eastern Pipistrelle | Perimyotis subflavus | | |
| Coyote | Canis latrans | | |
| Raccoon | Procyon lotor | | |
| Striped Skunk | Mephitis mephitis | | |
| Long-tailed Weasel | Mustela frenata | | |
| Mink | Neovison vison | ||
| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------ | |
| Northern Water Snake | Nerodia sipedon | | |
| Eastern Garter Snake | Thamnophis sirtalis sirtalis | | |
| Brown Snake | Storeria dekayi | | |
| Milk Snake | Lampropeltis triangulum | ||
| Five-lined Skink | Plestiodon (Eumeces) fasciatus | | |
| Midland Painted Turtle | Chrysemys picta marginata | | |
| Common Map Turtle | Graptemys geographica | | |
| Common Snapping Turtle | Chelydra serpentina | | |
| Eastern Spiny Softshell | Apalone spinifera spinifera | | |
| Bullfrog | Rana catesbeiana | | |
| Green Frog | Rana clamitans | | |
| Northern Leopard Frog | Rana pipiens | | |
| American Toad | Bufo americana | | |
| Gray Treefrog | Hyla versicolor | | |
| Western Chorus Frog | Pseudacris triseriata triseriata | | |
| Blanchard's Cricket Frog | Acris crepitans blanchardi | | |
| Spring Peeper | Pseudacris crucifer | | |
| Jefferson-like Ambystoma salamander | Ambystoma hybrid | | |
| Smallmouth Salamander | Ambystoma texanum | | |
| Tiger Salamander | Ambystoma tigrinum | | |
| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------ | |
| Grass Pickerel | Esox americanus | | |
| Green Sunfish | Lepomis cyanellus | | |
| Longear Sunfish | Lepomis megalotis | | |
| Bluegill | Lepomis macrochirus | | |
| Redear Sunfish | Lepomis microlophus | | |
| Largemouth Bass | Micropterus salmoides | | |
| Tadpole Madtom | Noturus gyrinus | | |
| Yellow Bullhead | Ameiurus natalis | | |
| Black Bullhead | Ameiurus melas | | |
| Common White Sucker | Catostomus commersonii | | |
| Central Stoneroller | Campostoma anomalum | | |
| Creek Chub | Semotilus atromaculatus | | |
| Striped Shiner | Luxilus chrysocephalus | | |
| Silverjaw Minnow | Notropis buccatus | | |
| Bluntnose Minnow | Pimephales notatus | | |
| Golden Shiner | Notemigonus crysoleucas | | |
| Redfin Shiner | Lythrurus umbratilis | | |
| Scarlet Shiner | Lythrurus fasciolaris | | |
| Johnny Darter | Etheostoma nigrum | | |
| Fantail Darter | Etheostoma flabellare | | |
| Greenside Darter | Etheostoma blennioides | | |
| Rainbow Darter | Etheostoma caeruleum | | |
| Orangethroat Darter | Etheostoma spectabile | | |
| Blackside Darter | Percina maculata | | |
| Blackstripe Topminnow | Fundulus notatus | |